Mthuli Ncube should learn from Masiyiwa

Mthuli Ncube should learn from Masiyiwa
Published: 15 March 2019 (196 Views)
Finance minister Mthuli Ncube's United States jaunt last week was always expected to yield what it yielded - an empty basket. It's no rocket science.

In an article published in this column last year titled Why Ncube will not get us debt relief, an argument was put forward that "The US cannot be ignored in our economic recovery matrix due to the influence it wields over multi-lateral institutions and their affiliates."

As Ncube was on his way to Washington to plead the case for Zimbabwe, Donald Trump, the US president, renewed sanctions on Harare citing that no meaningful political and economic reforms had been advanced by Harare, basically telling Ncube that no financial assistance was coming the way of Zimbabwe through international financial institutions (IFIs). Ncube thought he had a good story to tell about how he was generating a primary budget surplus, how he was containing the growth of money supply and how the country was letting free market forces rule as evidenced by the managed floating exchange rate.

Apparently, all this did not impress Trump. The column predicted all this last year when it carried the argument in the article titled Why the US won't come to the party, that "Here is the point that (President Emmerson) Mnangagwa and many economic analysts seem to be missing; the numerous pre-conditions for external funding outlined in Zidera such as freedom of expression and association, indisputable elections, addressing and redressing human rights abuses, for instance, are all subordinate to the key concern of property rights protection." Ncube, two weeks ago belatedly acknowledged that the issue of property rights in the context of compensation for farms forcibly acquired from white farmers was, in his own words, "the bigger elephant in the room". Shockingly, in the US last week, Ncube chose to talk about mice instead of the bigger elephant he had so accurately identified.

What is the solution now that chances of receiving debt relief and unlocking affordable external funding are next to zilch? This is where Strive Masiyiwa comes in. We are not about to ask Masiyiwa to fund the country, let alone asking him to use his powerful connections to help Zimbabwe get funding. It's about how he has succeeded in starting and growing his businesses in places where traditional entrepreneurs and Western business deem there was no money to make.

Enter Clayton Christensen, the father of the ground-breaking disruptive innovation model and Efosa Ojomo, the Nigerian and former MBA student of Christensen at the Harvard Business School. Together with Karen Dillon, Christensen and Ojomo have recently co-authored a book called The Prosperity Paradox: How Innovation Can Lift Nations out of Poverty, to explain the findings of their research on how disruptive innovations have lifted nations out of poverty and will continue bringing prosperity to nations.

Disruptive innovations are innovations that create new markets and pull in infrastructure and new supporting industries by making products and services once inaccessible to the majority of people simple to use and affordable. This is how Masiyiwa has made his money.

This is how Mo Ibrahim became a US dollar billionaire by making telephones accessible and affordable to the masses through mobile phones. This is how Henry Ford brought prosperity to America by making cars simpler and affordable to the average American. Similarly Masiyiwa, has launched disruptive innovation after disruptive innovation. EcoCash, EcoSure, these have enabled the unbanked and the uninsured to enjoy convenient and relatively cheaper banking services. Masiyiwa's latest disruptive innovation of introducing solar power to rural areas is promising to make electricity affordable and accessible to the majority of Zimbabweans (who live in rural areas).

The prosperity paradox is an extension of the disruptive innovation model to macro-economic development. I have confidence in this model because disruptive innovation is a classic grounded theory, meaning that it is based on uncovering the key concerns of a group of people. A journal article I wrote and was published in an international peer reviewed journal showed how and why disruptive innovation is a classic grounded theory. The extension of disruptive innovation to macro-economic development comes hardly as a surprise - it is simply an extension of a classic grounded theory to a new area of application.

What is this paradox? The paradox is that the accepted traditional model of economic development is that for economic development to happen, infrastructure and supporting structures must first be put in place to attract investment, yet disruptive innovation says when an innovation that creates a new market by pulling in the majority of people who prior did not consume a product or service, the necessary infrastructure and supporting economic networks will be pulled in, not pushed.

Highways were not needed before Henry Ford made cars affordable to average American through his famous Model T. When the Model T made cars affordable and accessible to the once excluded masses, the necessary infrastructure and supporting economic networks were pulled in - highways, car showrooms, parts retail, car insurance, parts manufacture, car repairs, out-of-town suburbs and second-hand car dealerships. Japan made cars affordable to the majority of people in the world through its sub-compact vehicles, disruptive innovations in their own right - massive industrial development was pulled in, not pushed as a result.

Typical of classic grounded theory, Christensen meticulously distinguishes types of innovations into three categories: market-creating (disruptive) innovations, sustaining innovations and efficiency innovations. These types of innovations have different impacts on economic development. Market-creating or disruptive innovations create massive employment. Sustaining innovations make good products better - they do not pull in new consumers, but existing consumers replace old versions with newer improved versions - the net effect on employment and economic development is marginal. Efficiency innovations reduce the production costs of the current product by eliminating waste, releasing more capital which usually finds no suitable home to invest. Efficiency innovations cause unemployment as people get retrenched to "right-size" organisations.

Zimbabwe's past prosperity was based on market-creating (disruptive innovations). Let us consider Bulawayo as an example. The former Cold Storage Commission (CSC) was a disruptive innovation - it made beef affordable and accessible to the majority of Zimbabweans. As a result, it pulled in massive infrastructure and supported a powerful economic network or cluster in Bulawayo. It supported the National Railways of Zimbabwe (NRZ) which transported cattle from the ranches (themselves part of the cluster pulled in by beef as a disruptive innovation). In turn, the NRZ pulled in a cluster of engineering firms that manufactured and repaired NRZ's wagons. The NRZ, the CSC and engineering firms were the largest employers in Bulawayo, contributing to Bulawayo's local tax revenue base that supported the Bulawayo City Council, itself a massive employer. Once land reformed disrupted disruptive innovation (pun not intended), the whole economic cluster in Bulawayo collapsed, hence Bulawayo's decay.

What is my point? Ncube and his advisors need to know that as a country we need to educate our nations to be disruptive innovators, finding out areas where the majority of Zimbabweans and Africans are not consuming because of lack of affordability. We disruptively innovate, creating new markets - the necessary infrastructure will be pulled in. For starters, let us re-disrupt by way of agriculture which was once a powerful disruptive innovation where products were made affordable and accessible to the majority of Zimbabweans. Make the farms productive once again. We have told Ncube before that the white farmers are offering government a deal where government pays nothing to compensate the white farmers - it is time he took this offer seriously - it is the only way out that will make us re-establish our once powerful agro-based disruptive innovations.

Brett Chulu is a management consultant and a classic grounded theory researcher who has published research in an academic peer-reviewed international journal. -

- the independent


You May Like These Videos


There are no comments.

Latest stories

Mnangagwa's advisors turn against Trevor Ncube

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 April 2019 | 44 Views

MDC Structures keep the dream alive, the Jewel of Africa returns

by Jacob Mafume | 20 April 2019 | 38 Views

Mnangagwa wedged between a rock and hard place

by Editorial - Daily News | 20 April 2019 | 38 Views

Chamisa demands face to face meeting with Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 20 April 2019 | 67 Views

PHOTOS: Bulawayo - Nkayi road construction

by Social media | 20 April 2019 | 63 Views

Credible team and sound advice ahead of Elective Congress

by A big Easter by Tinashe Eric Muzamhindo | 20 April 2019 | 51 Views

South Africa and Zimbabwe turn a blind eye

by Sipho Ndlovu | 20 April 2019 | 51 Views

If its about us let us know

by Thomas Murisa | 20 April 2019 | 47 Views

ZAA Canada announces inaugural nominees

by Staff reporter | 20 April 2019 | 55 Views

Mnangagwa scared of death via political foul play

by Itai Mushekwe | 20 April 2019 | 60 Views

VACANCY: Thomson Reuters Foundation is employing

by Mandla Ndlovu | 19 April 2019 | 155 Views

Mohadi goes to court, seeks protection against ex-wife

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 204 Views

Gukurahundi cannot be wished away: Williams

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 148 Views

ZANU PF MP and Zhuwawo agree with Chamisa

by Mandla Ndlovu | 19 April 2019 | 309 Views

Can Zimbabwe manage to de-dollarise?

by Victor Bhoroma | 19 April 2019 | 130 Views

Why Mthuli Ncube's new currency is likely to be doomed

by Martin Tarusenga | 19 April 2019 | 120 Views

Rebirth of the Zimdollar

by Paddington Masamha | 19 April 2019 | 139 Views

Gukurahundi healing, reconciliation timeframes set

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 112 Views

Angry Mnangagwa lashes 'unpatriotic and inhumane' forces

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 116 Views

India, UAE roped in to revive CAPS, Datlabs

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 100 Views

Zimbabwe civil servants demand fresh wage negotiations

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 107 Views

Police, courts corrupt, says Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 101 Views

Welshman Ncube not presidential material, MDC structures

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 104 Views

'39 years on Matebeleland still lags behind'

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 99 Views

Mnangagwa, Mugabe carefully planned Gukurahundi genocide

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 101 Views

Mnangagwa's fear over Gukurahundi

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 102 Views

Mnangagwa to launch Command Bakeries across the country

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 101 Views

Fake projects scandal: MP Musikavanhu plots to steal CDF

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 114 Views

Zanu-PF youths in solidarity march

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 113 Views

Rigging, vote-buying alleged at MDC Alliance provincial congress

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 99 Views

Judge blasts State over Chivayo appeal

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 98 Views

Zimbabweans told to brace for thunderstorms, wet Easter

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 107 Views

Zimbabwe will rise again, dreams Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 90 Views

Fire leaves Guinea Fowl High teachers homeless

by Staff reporter | 19 April 2019 | 92 Views