Who is worse between manipulating politician and gullible follower?

Who is worse between manipulating politician and gullible follower?
Published: 07 September 2018 (168 Views)
AFTER the unnecessarily contentious elections, Zimbabwe could be about to reset and, thus, reboot itself on its journey from dysfunctionality to functionality.

I say unnecessarily contentious because − if I may paraphrase 20th century United States Supreme Court judge Robert H Jackson − the Constitutional Court (ConCourt) is always right because it is final, not final because it is right. So, MDC Alliance presidential candidate Nelson Chamisa − with all his celebrated lawyers − should have known that and was, thus, least expected to condemn the ConCourt judgment throwing away his application to have President Emmerson Mnangagwa's electoral victory overturned. But Chamisa is still making noise about it, which noise we need to cut through. We need people who know what they are talking about, but these people − despite being lawyers − are doing more than they can and more than they should in threatening to appeal against an appeal at the African Commission on Human and People's Rights, whose effect is only that of prolonging uncertainty. United States Congresswoman Karen Bass also called on sobriety of mind: "The courts have ruled and that is the process, and so not to recognise him (Mnangagwa) as president, I don't know what that means." (The Standard, September 2 to 8 2018)

To compound that, some politicians are citing false dichotomies to make themselves appear in good light. A dichotomy is a set of two mutually exclusive, jointly exhaustive alternatives. A false dichotomy is typically used in an argument to force people into an extreme position − by making the assumption that there are only two positions. "You are either part of the solution or part of the problem" − no room for innocent bystanders here. "If you're not with us, you're against us" − being neutral is not an option, forcing people to classify themselves as either "with us" or "against us".

A false dichotomy is an attempt to force a person into choosing one of two seeming opposite extremes, not just one of two arbitrary answers. That is why "If you're not with us, you're against us" is a false dichotomy − because the two alternatives are presented as opposite extremes.

Cynical politicians, according to Chaz Bufe in a paper titled Political False Dichotomies (March 31, 2015), use this device and subtefuge of false dichotomy for several reasons.

One, false dichotomy is used to bypass their listeners' reasoning faculty, all too easy a task; for instance, by projecting Advocate Thabani Mpofu as a hero for representing Chamisa in the Concourt pro bono or for free and, going by the emotiveness of the issue, effectively lying by omission by not mentioning that the very same Mpofu also served to legalise Mnangagwa's position as President by successfully arguing in the Supreme Court in December 2017 that Mnangangwa had been duly appointed after the ouster of former president Robert Mugabe the previous month. This omission has the effect of creating the false dichotomy that there are exclusively Zanu-PF lawyers and also those solely MDC lawyers.

Two, false dichotomy is used to influence their listeners into only considering two, almost invariably bad, alternatives, rather than looking for others, whereas in real life it's blended solutions that work.

Three, false dichotomy is used to cement the support of followers who accept the false dichotomy, such as that God is on the side of their party and, therefore, accommodating the other side is associating with pure evil. Those claiming biblical justification ought to know that they have no monopoly over interpretation of the Bible, as other Christians see things completely differently.

Four, to rouse their followers into a frenzy of hatred against those to whom they are impugning false beliefs or goals because they know that there is some truth in every lie such as because Zanu-PF has been brutal before like during the Gukurahundi massacres, it will be brutal again. But that line is being bought less and less going by the much increased vote for Zanu-PF in both Matabeleland North and Matabeleland South provinces in the July 30 elections.

It's good for the political culture of Zimbabwe when people think for themselves. They should not be like some Victoria Falls residents, who are already regretting their voting choices as they face the dilemma of having a mayor not of their liking, with one resident bemoaning "People voted with anger, revenge and unstable minds. What they wanted was change and, as a result, they voted for a brand, forgetting the quality of a leader, especially the councillors, and that is why we are in this situation."

And, five, to intimidate those who hold other positions into silence, because of fear of physical violence from the politicians' deluded followers. Well, we saw that during the funeral of MDC-T leader Morgan Tsvangirai in February this year when party vice-president Elias Mudzuri had to make a hasty and unceremonious retreat after being threatened by the menacing so-called MDC-T vanguard and his counterpart Thokozani Khupe was physically attacked by the same mob at Tsvangirai's burial.

Observed a blogger: "One way to shatter false dichotomies is to look at what both sides might have in common - and I don't mean 'extremism'. Sometimes you will find a commonality so important that the two 'opposites' will look like brothers."

Well, MDC Alliance vice-president Mudzuri has done just that by pointing out this week the increasing common interests between Zanu-PF and MDC. Mudzuri has come out and declared that he is above such small-minded internecine fights. It's bold and courageous of him. I do not doubt the sincerity of Mudzuri, one of the top officials in both Zanu-PF and MDC I have had the pleasure to make acquaintance with − yes, I practice the entente cordiale (friendly understanding) and modus vivendi (an arrangement allowing conflicting parties to coexist in peace and co-operation) that I preach.

This week Mudzuri said: "There is not much debate on working together or not because what has happened is that we are in control of the local authorities and the central government is under Zanu-PF," Mudzuri said. "We need to tolerate each other." Indeed, the nation needs Mudzuri's mature reciprocity because there is actually now much more in common between Zanu-PF and MDC, as their party manifestos were hardly distinguishable from each other.

In 2014 at the height of political polarisation, Mudzuri attended Heroes' Day commemmorations on his own to show his political courage, sending the message to both Zanu-PF and his own party, MDC, that he was above the fray. For any party not to be mired in boisterous but empty talk, it needs such a maverick − a politician who takes an independent stand apart from his or her associates.

Going back to Bufe, he observed: "It's hard to say which is worse − that politicians routinely employ false dichotomies or that their followers routinely fall for them. The logical fallacy in false dichotomies is very obvious, but a great many people don't see the fallacy. Many even mouth false-dichotomy assertions as if they are clever or to make a point."

Indeed, who is worse between the lying politician and the gullible follower?

Conway Nkumbuzo Tutani is a Harare-based columnist. Email: nkumbuzo@gmail.com

- newsday


You May Like These Videos


There are no comments.

Latest stories

Man loses 'Toyota Raum' to robbers

by Simbarashe Sithole | 21 September 2018 | 216 Views

International media stampede to interview Mnangagwa

by Staff Reporter | 21 September 2018 | 281 Views

Brutalising vendors must stop

by Jacob Mafume, MDC National Spokesperson | 21 September 2018 | 204 Views

I doubt if Dabengwa really endorsed Mnangagwa - Mthwakazi activist

by Stephen Jakes | 21 September 2018 | 199 Views

Marc Cayeux gives everyone hope after top ten finish in Cape Town

by Agencies | 21 September 2018 | 117 Views

President Mnangagwa debuts at UNGA

by Bevan Musoko | 21 September 2018 | 173 Views

BREAKING: Harare - Johannesburg Intercape bus in accident, 10 people dead

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 334 Views

Stop unnecessary traveling to cholera affected areas - MIHR

by Stephen Jakes | 21 September 2018 | 131 Views

We need Mthwakazi restoration soon

by Stephen Jakes | 21 September 2018 | 130 Views

Rural development agenda should be on the priority list

by Stephen Jakes | 21 September 2018 | 124 Views

IMF offers to help Zimbabwe clear arrears

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 245 Views

Mugabe's party rejoins Mnangagwa's Zanu-PF

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 253 Views

Streak seeks ZC liquidation

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 156 Views

'Chamisa must not waste time fighting Mnangagwa'

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 264 Views

Chipanga appeal thrown out

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 192 Views

New minister cracks the whip

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 197 Views

Deal decisively with Parly delinquents

by Zvamaida Murwira | 21 September 2018 | 156 Views

Mthuli Ncube faces tough choices

by Lovemore Chikova | 21 September 2018 | 181 Views

Currency reform answer to Zimbabwe's economic woes

by Bongani Ngwenya | 21 September 2018 | 164 Views

Dabengwa ditches Chamisa, endorses Mnangagwa?

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 171 Views

Sibusiso Moyo alive & well

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 153 Views

'Mugabe University not a priority'

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 144 Views

Chamisa battles open rebellion

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 169 Views

Prophet up for pregnant woman rape

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 104 Views

Bulawayo pins hopes on devolution

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 97 Views

Nust shut down

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 154 Views

Zimbabweans want US or Zim dollar only, not SA Rand

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 151 Views

Chamisa's MDC Alliance starts merging into single party

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 102 Views

Vic Falls man hangs self after bar brawl

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 88 Views

Cholera hits Beitbridge

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 86 Views

Cop up for assault

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 57 Views

Gumbura hires Madhuku to challenge delayed trial

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 68 Views

Devolution will develop provinces with natural resources

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 58 Views

Family evicted, dumped in the bush

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 55 Views

Soul Brothers coming to Bulawayo

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 119 Views

Zimbabwean scientist wins Cambridge scholarship

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 60 Views

MDC Alliance activist jailed over arson threats

by Staff reporter | 21 September 2018 | 47 Views