July 30 election: Not free, fair or credible

July 30 election: Not free, fair or credible
Published: 20 July 2018 (163 Views)
As things stand at present, it is evident that these elections cannot be called free, fair or credible without some remarkable changes taking place.

The fast approaching elections in Zimbabwe are cause for great concern. Far too many critical aspects of the process have been shrouded in secrecy or reluctantly conceded using rigid legal criteria and no discretionary interpretation to build confidence. The continued arrogance and lack of separation of both the state and the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) from the ruling party, requires challenging by the electorate that has expressed mounting concern about the credibility and transparency of the agency tasked to conduct this election.

Key critical events leading to this crisis of confidence include the 2008 elections where the military directly intervened to prevent a transfer of power, a fact admitted publicly and privately by senior politicians within the ruling party.

The failure of the African community, notably Sadc and the African Union, to comprehensively resolve the 2008 crisis remains a cause of the current problems. By both tacitly endorsing the role of the military by failure to sanction the violence, and the weak response to five years of reform resistance by Zanu-PF during the Global Political Agreement, this enhanced the confidence of the military leadership to continue on their trajectory of militarisation of all aspects of the state and independent institutions.

Following the disputed 2013 elections, the region and international community remained ambivalent toward escalating tension and divisions within all political parties. In particular, Zanu-PF, driven by succession battles and a deteriorating economy, was unable to govern effectively and this contributed to the events of November 2017. There was a weak response to the military undertaking "corrective action" to resolve an internal crisis within Zanu-PF, nor any credible response to two dubious judgments in the Supreme Court aimed at sanitising the military intervention. This ambivalence has granted the military increasing confidence to meddle in all aspects of civilian rule and life.

The questionable reluctance to address the power transfer by its correct name, a military coup, creates the proximal challenges for the elections scheduled on July 30. It is clear to all Zimbabweans that the elections have been linked to sanitising the coup outcome by the region and international community. It is also clear that the promises by the "new dispensation" to institute state reform, transparency and accountability are not being honoured by either the civilian government or the military.

While it is to a small extent understandable that there was reluctance by both the international community and Zimbabwean political parties to forthrightly call this intervention a coup, this failure is a proximal cause of the problems with the elections scheduled for later this month.

The consequence has been replaced by the requirement that the elections meet a higher standard than is usual, and has become the condition for international re-engagement. This requires a much more robust engagement by the government and the international community on the conditions for these elections.

The key to this outcome was promised by the "new dispensation" as accountable and transparent government, with an emphasis on reforming the state. There is no evidence that the government has delivered any reforms of any consequence outside of those aimed at the economy. There is no evidence that the "new dispensation" has shown any commitment to good governance, rule of law and adherence to human rights, and, even more seriously, to a commitment to constitutionalism.

Two examples amongst many will illustrate this. The first is the lack of response by the government to the court ruling against Chief Fortune Charumbira and the Council of Chiefs' statement to support Zanu-PF in the 2018 elections. Rather than insist that the court decision be obeyed as per the constitution and the law, the government has allowed Charumbira to challenge the decision.

The second is a similar lack of response to the rulings by both the Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission and the Masvingo High Court on the compelled involvement of schoolchildren in political rallies.

To these two small examples must be added the deployment of soldiers in civilian attire into rural communities, the partisan distribution of food and agricultural inputs and the complete failure to reform the partisan state media and broadcasting services. This all indicates the complete lack of crucial reforms necessary for establishing a level playing field.

The technical aspects of the election must be added to these problems. Here, the complete lack of confidence in Zec, stated increasingly more vigorously by political parties, and supported by the views of ordinary citizens captured in opinion polls, only deepens the growing crisis.

In sum, the minimal conditions for the holding of free, fair and credible elections are wholly absent. As such, we note with increasing alarm the noticeable lack of open expression of concern by the international community and international observers. The differences between the views of most Zimbabweans and the international community seem to suggest that we might all be living in different countries. This is not trivial, and we fear once again the adverse consequences of the lack of muscular reaction by the international community to flawed elections and stolen political power.

In order that these elections have any prospect of being regarded as minimally free, fair and credible, three urgent actions must be undertaken by the government with the active support of the international community.

Firstly, the matter of the printing of the ballot papers must be resolved by a transparent and fully observed printing in all its aspects; and likewise the collation and distribution of the ballots to province and constituency. While time might not allow any change of printing, all other aspects must be transparently observed by all stakeholders.

Secondly, on the matter of the voters' roll, all irregularities must be dealt with in a transparent and urgent manner, with an independent audit. Electronic copies of the roll must be readily available to all that request this, whether political parties, candidates or citizens.

Thirdly, there must be removal of all the military personnel currently deployed within the communities in the country. This should be observed and audited by a multi-party group that includes representatives of the major international observer missions.

Mandaza and Reeler are the conveners of Platform for Concerned Citizens.

- the independnet

Tags: Election, Free, Fair,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Woman found guilty of lust

by Simbarashe Sithole | 20 August 2018 | 301 Views

Paul Siwela: Lion King that is about to roar

by Israel Dube | 20 August 2018 | 177 Views

Chiwenga represents the 'New Disorder' not New Dispensation

by Knowledge Hakata | 20 August 2018 | 260 Views

Tajamuka demands courts to swear in Chamisa

by Stephen Jakes | 20 August 2018 | 259 Views

Chamisa urges fasting, prayers for crunch Wednesday hearing

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 193 Views

Deportation of Tendai Biti low, low point for Zambian regime

by Prof. Michelo Hansungule | 20 August 2018 | 110 Views

Why Biti was deported from Zambia

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 192 Views

Chamisa's heads of argument in Con-Court showdown - FULL-TEXT

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 309 Views

Woman found gift of lust

by Simbarashe Sithole | 20 August 2018 | 118 Views

Mathuthu gets hero's send-off

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 97 Views

A journey well completed

by Emmerson Mnangagwa | 20 August 2018 | 102 Views

Chamisa election petition latest

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 184 Views

Constitutional Court to set number of precedents

by Editorial - the herald | 20 August 2018 | 118 Views

Devolution a priority, says Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 61 Views

Jockeying for Kwekwe mayoral post begins

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 82 Views

Harare Poly gets nod to offer media degree

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 65 Views

Three eye Masvingo mayoral post

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 93 Views

What sin did Ariel Sibanda commit Mr Chidzambwa?

by Sikhumbuzo Moyo | 20 August 2018 | 98 Views

'We'll not mourn,' says Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 100 Views

Zimbabwe inflation reaches record high since 2012

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 94 Views

Mnangagwa pays tribute to Kofi Annan

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 81 Views

Democracy, elections bad for collective cause

by Reason Wafawarova | 20 August 2018 | 74 Views

Son 'kills' mum over 50c

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 92 Views

'Devolution key to economic development'

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 58 Views

MDC Alliance candidate petition hearing date set

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 78 Views

Hunter challenges conviction, sentence

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 55 Views

Industry expresses concern over poor quality imports

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 67 Views

Police boss blocked from probing cop

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 63 Views

Teenage woman kills hubby

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 76 Views

Woman in trouble after accusing neighbour of lust

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 51 Views

Madlela set to launch album

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 64 Views

Chamisa court case broadcast commendable, but ...

by Editorial - mewsday | 20 August 2018 | 107 Views

Zanu-PF plots at witch-hunt over 'bhora musango'

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 45 Views

Duo electrocuted in attempted cable theft

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 38 Views

'Mnangagwa's Biti tweet misconstrued'

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 89 Views

Divisions rock Zanu-PF

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 57 Views

Nobuntu dazzles Bulawayo fans

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2018 | 88 Views