Mthuli Ncube's desperate bid facing a sharp court challenge

Mthuli Ncube's desperate bid facing a sharp court challenge
Published: 16 October 2018 (324 Views)
Finance minister Mthuli Ncube's desperate bid to balance the government's shambolic books by raising the State's revenue through an unpopular new tax is facing a sharp court challenge.

This comes after a prominent civic leader filed an urgent application in the High Court yesterday, seeking to reverse the minister's controversial two cents per transacted dollar new tax which became effective at the weekend.

Ncube is yet to file his opposing papers in the case.

The chief executive of the Combined Harare Residents Association, Mfundo Mlilo, said in his papers that the much-criticised tax is illegal as its regulations - announced in a Government Gazette last Friday - had not been affirmed by Parliament.

Legally, a Cabinet minister cannot alone change an Act of Parliament as the august House is the only body mandated to repeal such laws.

"It is my contention that the Intermediated Money Transfer Tax, like any tax, has to be legislated for through regulations and in the particular case of a tax through Parliament.

"Without the law it is my contention that the respondent's actions are a nullity. The respondent did not comply with the above. He did not table any Finance Act.

"He literally made an announcement in a beer hall and expects Zimbabweans to be bound by an announcement made in a pub," Mlilo said in his challenge.

"Indeed pursuant to the provision of Section 36G ... Section 22G of the Finance Act currently provides that, the Intermediated Money Transfer Tax chargeable in terms of Section 36G of the Taxes Act shall be calculated at the rate of $0.05 for each transaction exceeding $10 on which the tax is payable.

"Therefore, the Import of Section 22G is that a fixed charge of $0.05 is chargeable on every transaction exceeding $10," he added.

"The fact of the matter is that section 22G has not been repealed and remains the only lawful tax chargeable on such transactions.

"It follows that the minister's directive to all financial institutions, banks and Zimra working together with Telecommunications Companies to collect US$0.02 per every dollar is unlawful and a nullity as it infringes Section 22G of the Finance Act," he argued further.

Mlilo's challenge comes as the much-disliked tax became operational on Friday after it was gazetted by the government following a tumultuous two weeks in which long-suffering citizens rejected it outright as they felt that it further worsens their economic situation.

Ncube has also been criticised heavily for not consulting sufficiently on the matter, as first reported by the Daily News - with his colleagues in government and Zanu-PF bigwigs laying the blame on him for the current volatility in the country's sickly economy.

The under-pressure minister - who had earlier vowed that he would not go back on his controversial tax - was later forced to eat humble pie when he was compelled by his bosses to review the tax.

But the tweaked tax has still failed to douse the raging fires as the economy has remained in dire straits - as highlighted by empty supermarket shelves and the closure of some prominent retail and fast food outlets.

Meanwhile, the main opposition MDC and radical pressure group Tajamuka have put the government on notice - and are pushing for rolling protests against the deteriorating economic environment in the country, as well as the two cents per dollar tax.

This follows a police crackdown on the country's labour leaders who had attempted to organise last Thursday's foiled protests against the controversial tax.

When Ncube presented his new measures at the beginning of the month, he laid bare the extent of the government's problems - revealing that its domestic debt had ballooned from $276 million in 2012 to nearly $10 billion today.

In addition, Zimbabwe's external debt now also stands at $7,4 billion - bringing the country's total debt to $17 billion.

Ncube said driving the government's huge debt was the issuance of tradable paper that it uses to borrow from banks - Treasury Bills (TBs) - which had increased from $2,1 billion in 2016 to a staggering $7,6 billion by the end of August this year.

In his court challenge, Mlilo further argued that the two cents per dollar tax was irrational as the government's lavish and wasteful spending had created the current situation.

"It is therefore irrational for the same government to then fault us and increase the costs of the same (transactions).

"The government is subject to the rule of law. Its decisions can be challenged on the basis of irrationality," he contested.

President Emmerson Mnangagwa, 76 - who was elected as Zimbabwe's substantive leader in the hotly-disputed July 30 national elections - has been working hard to revive the country's battered economy.

But while most Zimbabweans warmly received his recent Cabinet picks - in which he dumped the old guard which had been a permanent feature in ousted former leader Robert Mugabe's previous government - his administration's latest policy initiatives have drawn significant public scorn.

- dailynews

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

War vets slam bread price hike

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 36 Views

Charumbira calls for truce in boundary row

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 34 Views

Mnangagwa hopeful on economy

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 34 Views

Revolution is the great teacher

by Reason Wafawarova | 22 April 2019 | 23 Views

Econet raises RTGS$479 287 for Idai relief through EcoCash

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 28 Views

Chief Mvuthu's family in fresh wrangle

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 33 Views

'Mnangagwa to crack whip on errand businesses'

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 32 Views

Artisanal miner shot dead

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 31 Views

'Zimbabwe public finances in bad shape'

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 23 Views

It's time for South Africa to rethink the economy

by Tapiwa Gomo | 22 April 2019 | 23 Views

'Mnangagwa won't take Zimbabwe anywhere'

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 32 Views

Military rifle recovered from poachers

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 28 Views

MDC led council not going back on tariff increase

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 30 Views

Mnangagwa told to be realistic

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 33 Views

'Wanton price hikes signify indiscipline'

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 25 Views

Where is Mnangagwa taking us to?

by Eddie Cross | 22 April 2019 | 26 Views

Rank marshal jailed over witchcraft rant

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 30 Views

Bosso brace for Triangle

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 25 Views

Confusion over Sadomba suspension

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 26 Views

Fraudulent clerk of court denied bail

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 26 Views

Zimra moves towards single clearance at ports of entry

by Staff reporter | 22 April 2019 | 16 Views

PHOTOS: Wicknell Chivayo carrying US$1 million in cash

by Mandla Ndlovu | 22 April 2019 | 17 Views

Genocide: A tool used by Mashonaland to demonise Ndebeles

by Mqondisi Moyo | 22 April 2019 | 23 Views

Mnangagwa lied about his arrest by whites?

by Mandla Ndlovu | 22 April 2019 | 16 Views

'Biti and Welshman Ncube must not contest at congress'

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 172 Views

Multiple inconsistencies in Mr Multiverse Dungani's article.

by Thulani Nkala | 21 April 2019 | 98 Views

Zanu-PF begins constitutional amendments

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 161 Views

WATCH: Pastor kisses a woman to remove a demon

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 193 Views

'Mnangagwa's advisor is a CIO double agent'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 222 Views

'Mnangagwa and Enock Sithole were not crocodile gang members'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 151 Views

President Mnangagwa's Easter message to Zimbabwe

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 110 Views

WATCH: Chiyangwa turns his 34 bedroom house into a hotel

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 145 Views

George Charamba gets baptism of fire

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 126 Views

Dreaded CIO Minister in fresh mine wrangle storm

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 117 Views

Matebeleland Collective a ZANU PF and British creation?

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 86 Views

Criminals cash in on lost IDs, certificates

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 101 Views