Tax war spills into court

Tax war spills into court
Published: 15 October 2018 (247 Views)
Government's decision to charge a draconian two percent tax on electronic transactions is likely to face its first legal challenge today.

The Daily News can report that a Harare man, Mfundo Mlilo, is approaching the High Court today, seeking to have the tax reversed on grounds that it is "illegal and immoral."

Mlilo who is a director of the Combined Harare Residents' Association is challenging the lawfulness of the tax in his personal capacity.

He is arguing that the country's legal system does not allow government to repeal sections of an Act of Parliament without being debated and passed by the National Assembly.

"The respondent is the Finance minister Mthuli Ncube and the case is being argued by Tendai Biti," Mlilo told the Daily News.

"Our contention is that the purported increase is unlawful because the minister has purported to change a section of an Act of Parliament which in itself is unconstitutional as he should have tabled a Bill in Parliament first, which he has not done.

"We argue that the tax in itself is irrational because the government has been excessively borrowing and now that it has a runaway public debt it is now turning to citizens to cover up for its expenditure. We have no idea what the money was used for."

This comes as financial institutions, the Zimbabwe Revenue Authority and telecommunication companies on Saturday began extending the collection of the tax across all electronic transactions.

Introduced by Ncube last week, the two cents per dollar tax will not apply on transactions which are $10 or less.

There is a cap of $10 000 on the amount of tax to be paid, which means that transfers above $500 000 will attract a flat tax of $10 000.

Government gazetted the tax on Friday, resulting in retailers and other service providers reflecting the increase in their pricing.

Mlilo is insistent that while the tax does not respect the rule of law, it also takes away citizens' rights.

"Government through its own policies (of ease of doing business) forced citizens to use RTGS, mobile money and electronic transactions to the extent that 95 percent of all retail transactions are done electronically. It's unfair for the same government to then turn around and punish citizens for following policy," he said.

"Further, money is private property and the way this tax is designed, it is predatory and meant to infringe on our rights to property. In addition there has not been
sufficient consultations as a number of stakeholders if not most of industry was not consulted."

Legal observers are also of the view that the country's legal system does not allow government to repeal sections of an Act of Parliament without going through the National Assembly.

Harare lawyer, Obert Gutu, was quoted over the weekend saying ordinarily sections of an Act of Parliament cannot be repealed by a Statutory Instrument, which is a subsidiary piece of legislation that has to be anchored on a valid Act of Parliament.

"The Finance Act can only be lawfully repealed through the relevant Parliamentary processes and definitely not via a Statutory Instrument," opined Gutu.

Other legal experts also argued during the weekend that the law was a sign of government's continued disregard for procedural law which started with Ncube's attempt on October 1 2018 to give immediate effect to the two percent intermediated money transfer tax, through a ministerial statement.

Top Harare lawyer Chris Mhike said a decision as far-reaching and as material to the content of the Finance as the two percent tax on transaction must; naturally, logically and legally speaking, first be debated and passed by Parliament before being made into law.

"Through this new tax, government seeks to take away citizens' vested rights, in violation of Section 3 of the Constitution, that is the Founding Values and Principles upon which Zimbabwe is founded," said Mhike.

Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs minister Ziyambi Ziyambi declined to comment when contacted by the Daily News yesterday.

- dailynews

Tags: Tax, Court, War,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Deadly ZANU PF officials plot to oust Mnangagwa

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 January 2019 | 4 Views

Emotions charge up as Army victims are buried

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 January 2019 | 6 Views

BREAKING: Mnangagwa dumps Davos trip and heads home

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 January 2019 | 485 Views

Kazakhstan firms keen on Zimbabwe investment

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 173 Views

No South African bailout for Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 302 Views

Zimbabwe security services to use brutal force

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 318 Views

Zimbabwe on brink of diplomatic row with US, Germany

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 349 Views

Econet to reimburse subscribers over shutdown

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 155 Views

BREAKING: MDC Chairperson Tabitha Khumalo goes into hiding

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 January 2019 | 205 Views

Four simple Rules to solve the Zim financial crisis

by Colls Ndlovu | 20 January 2019 | 266 Views

'Dodgy' NGO blasts Mnangagwa's government

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 453 Views

Bulawayo looting had SA flare

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 247 Views

Cry my beloved Zimbabwe . . . as country is closed for business

by Staff rpeorter | 20 January 2019 | 192 Views

Zimbabwe's horror 2019 unfolds

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 266 Views

Price hikes fail to end fuel crisis

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 164 Views

Mnangagwa faces uphill task to re-engage world

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 164 Views

Security roadblocks all-over Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 162 Views

Mnangagwa must just do the right thing

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 175 Views

Soldiers warn organisers of last week's demonstrations

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 240 Views

Chamisa's violence streak

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 185 Views

MDC hawks in the dock

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 143 Views

Mnangagwa forges ties with Azerbaijan

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 168 Views

Zimbabwe counts cost of violent stay-away

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 180 Views

Zanu PF goes mad – Zimbabwe Vigil Diary

by ZimVigil | 20 January 2019 | 183 Views

Felton Kamambo defines his reign

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 118 Views

'Chamisa and his allies will be held accountable'

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 139 Views

MDC-Alliance's orgy of violence

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 146 Views

Is Chiyangwa behind board divisions?

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 134 Views

'Mnangagwa, take us back to Egypt!'

by Bishop Lazarus | 20 January 2019 | 154 Views

Chitungwiza looters are well-known

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 122 Views

'Information as a threat to national security'

by Senator Monica Mutsvangwa | 20 January 2019 | 164 Views

Govt avails $1 per route buses

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 144 Views

Civil servants start receiving allowances

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 152 Views

Fuel deliveries resume

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 135 Views

Fifa to pay $8 million Zifa debts

by Staff reporter | 20 January 2019 | 113 Views