Court defers ruling on Nduna's Chegutu West win

Court defers ruling on Nduna's Chegutu West win
Published: 19 September 2018 (349 Views)
The verdict in the Electoral Court challenge to newly-sworn-in legislator Dexter Nduna (Zanu-PF) accused by MDC Alliance rival Gift Konjana of stealing the Chegutu West National Assembly seat was postponed to Monday.

The Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) had initially announced Nduna as the winner with 10 932 votes, and Konjana with 10 828 votes. Konjana challenged the result, claiming the electoral body mixed up the figures.

While Zec reportedly admitted to have made an error, the electoral body advised Konjana that the results could only be overturned by the Electoral Court.

This prompted Konjana to file a petition with the Electoral Court in Harare seeking the nullification of Nduna's declaration, adding a tabulation error occurred and prejudiced him of 120 votes that had been erroneously awarded to one Simon Kache of UCADPGPZ.

Following claims by Konjana, the Electoral Court had set Monday as the date to pass judgment.

Magistrate Mary Zimba-Dube who presided over the matter postponed the ruling to next Monday to allow the parties to bring more evidence.

Nduna, in his heads of argument maintains that the Electoral Court does not have the jurisdictional ability to nullify a declaration made by the electoral body and thereafter pronounce an alternative winner.

He also claims that Zec and Konjana worked hand in glove to forge signatures of polling agents as they played around with figures allegedly to ensure Konjana is declared the winner.

A case of fraud has since been filed with the police against Kundai Goremusandu, who was a presiding officer at one polling station in the constituency, according to Nduna.

"The relief the petitioner (Konjana) seeks is irregular in that it is not contemplated by statute. Firstly, the petitioner predicates his cause on section 66 (4) (a) of the Electoral Act. Under such provision the Electoral Court only has power to 'set aside' a declaration and go no further.

"Under this provision the said court cannot 'nullify' a declaration and thereafter pronounce an alternative winner as prayed for by the petitioner. This is incompetent relief," Nduna argued.

"In terms of section 66 (4) (c) as read with section 67A of the Electoral Act, this court only has power to declare another candidate the winner of an election after a recount of votes. The petitioner is therefore asking the court to exercise powers beyond the jurisdictional ability of the statutory provision he seeks to rely on. An exercise of power beyond the jurisdictional ability of a court is irregular and void ad initio…."

Besides the jurisdictional ability of the Electoral Court, Nduna further said Konjana's petition was afflicted with a myriad of procedural irregularities and therefore urged the court to dismiss it.

"As better explained herein below, the noncompliance with the rules and the strict dicta of statute is fatal to the proceedings and should actuate the dismissal of the petition," he said.

"Put plainly, this matter must turn on a question of law rather than the facts, which if carefully considered, would still not substantiate the petitioner's prayer."

Nduna argued the present petition is strange.

"In the draft order the petitioner then seeks to impugn a declaration made by a constituency election officer, who is not named. In fact, the draft order doesn't even state the date when the declaration was made . . . the present petition does violence to this rule by describing an incomplete prayer on the face of the petition and then alluding to differently wondered relief in the draft order," he said.


- dailynews

Tags: Chegutu, Nduna, Win,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

'Zimbabwe reeling from socio-economic, challenges'

by Staff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 0 Views

Ncube slams door on US$ wage demands by doctors

by newzimbabwe | 17 December 2018 | 6 Views

Senior doctors join strike as crisis escalates

by ZimLive | 17 December 2018 | 4 Views

Mnangagwa promotes army officers

by Staff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 18 Views

Chidhakwa magistrate recusal bid fails

by Staff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 21 Views

One killed, three injured as bus is attacked before Beitbridge

by Staff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 27 Views

Intercape driver arrested trying to skip border to Zimbabwe

by STaff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 19 Views

12 law firms put under curatorship, 2 lawyers de-registered

by Ndou Paul | 17 December 2018 | 21 Views

Mphoko's son freed on bail

by Staff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 16 Views

Mnangagwa, Chamisa could learn from Mandela's humility

by Editorial - newsday | 17 December 2018 | 25 Views

ARTUZ teachers not charged, proceed with march

by Staff reporter | 17 December 2018 | 18 Views

BCC ignores burst sewer in my yard

by Tshabalala Resident | 17 December 2018 | 17 Views

Mnangagwa promotes August 1 massacre commander

by ZimLive | 17 December 2018 | 19 Views

BREAKING: Mnangagwa promotes 1 August killings commander

by Collen Ncube | 17 December 2018 | 14 Views

Mnangagwa fingered in ZBC saga

by Mandla Ndlovu | 17 December 2018 | 19 Views

ZIMRA goes after Harare City Council

by Collen Ncube | 17 December 2018 | 19 Views

Mnangagwa confronted

by Collen Ncube | 17 December 2018 | 16 Views

Mthuli Ncube calls doctors' demands 'nonsensical'

by Collen Ncube | 17 December 2018 | 24 Views

Zanu-PF OKs Mnangagwa as its 2023 candidate

by AP | 15 December 2018 | 132 Views

ZANU PF to ammend constitution

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 237 Views

China tells Zimbabwe 'Don't blame us, sort your own house'

by Staff reporter | 15 December 2018 | 362 Views

MDC Alliance losing Cllr jailed

by Staff reporter | 15 December 2018 | 177 Views

Mnangagwa donates 1 000 goats to schools

by Staff reporter | 15 December 2018 | 176 Views

PHOTOS: Bomb found at ZBC studios

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 162 Views

PHOTOS: MDC gala dinner held in Harare

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 159 Views

Kalawa Homecoming in disappointing line-up

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 127 Views

Mnangagwa's Important Speech

by Tom Nkala | 15 December 2018 | 146 Views

Mutsvangwa, Mangwana in messy fight with Energy Mutodi?

by Staff reporter | 15 December 2018 | 267 Views

Harare City Council owes $ 792 million

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 154 Views

Police crush teachers' protest demo

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 204 Views

Mnangagwa re-introduces Green Bombers

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 231 Views

Mnangagwa exposes Muchinguri-Kashiri lie

by newzimbabwe | 15 December 2018 | 251 Views

Zimbabwe doctors using condoms as medical gloves?

by ZimLive | 15 December 2018 | 182 Views

Mutsvangwa; Mangwana in messy fight with Energy Mutodi?

by Staff reporter | 15 December 2018 | 197 Views

Panic as Air Zimbabwe leaves passenger bags in South Africa

by Mandla Ndlovu | 15 December 2018 | 215 Views

Chamisa's MDC can go hang, says VP Chiwenga

by Staf reporter | 15 December 2018 | 206 Views

Government assures murdered lawyer's family of justice

by Staff reporter | 15 December 2018 | 169 Views