Kasukuwere set free

Kasukuwere set free
Published: 22 August 2019 (257 Views)
The High Court halted former local government minister Saviour Kasukuwere's trial on Wednesday after ruling that charges filed by prosecutors did not disclose an offence.

A magistrate's refusal to grant Kasukuwere's exception to the charges on that basis was "wrong in law, common sense and logic," said Justice Tawanda Chitapi.

Kasukuwere was charged on two counts of criminal abuse of office relating to land allocations he allegedly made while he was minister, and another two counts relating to the appointment of Brainworks as advisors to the National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board without going to tender.

The former minister made an application of exception to the charges at the Magistrate's Court, but magistrate Hosea Mujaya rejected threw out his application, and suggested Kasukuwere and his defence team were seeking to buy time.

In a devastating judgement released on Wednesday, Justice Chitapi said the magistrate had come across as "excitable" and made comments that were "unfortunate if not injudicious" while denying Kasukuwere a fair hearing.

Prosecutor Zivanai Macharaga had failed to pay due regard to Kasukuwere's fair trial rights, the judge went on, by withholding information requested by Kasukuwere in preparation of his defence.

Granting Kasukuwere's appeal against the dismissal of his exception application by the lower court, Justice Chitapi gave the following order: "a) The first respondent (Mujaya) ruling dismissing the applicant's exception to the charges is hereby set aside.

"b) The failure to allege essential averments on the standards and procedures which the applicant ought to have followed and allegedly acted contrary to or inconsistently with his duty as well as a failure to allege the duties which the applicant abrogated vitiates the charge sheet and renders it a nullity. The charge sheet is accordingly quashed in respect of all the four counts.

"c) In the event that the Prosecutor General determines to prosecute the applicant on any amended charges, the fresh proceedings shall be commenced before a different magistrate other than the first respondent, Hosea Mujaya Esquire."

He did not make an order on costs.

Justice Chitapi said it was not enough for prosecutors to arrest public officials and charge them with "acting contrary or inconsistent with their duties" without disclosing what those duties were.

"I must at once express my surprise at the apparent belligerent, hostile and argumentative posture which was adopted by second respondent as prosecutor," the judge said of Macharaga, a member of a controversial prosecution unit set up by President Emmerson Mnangagwa.

"What counsel submitted in essence was that it was not necessary for the charge to disclose or allege procedures which should have been followed nor indeed the applicant's duties in that regard. The attitude was more of a refusal to disclose material information or facts as would enable the applicant to plead an informed plea.

"… it just defies logic and legal reasoning for the prosecution to argue that the standard or the norm in regard to which an accused has deviated is not an essential element of a charge of criminal abuse of duty."

The judge said it was "alarming" for the prosecutor to argue that the duty that Kasukuwere allegedly failed in performing or performed corruptly would be disclosed "in evidence" during the trial.

"A public officer is invariably charged to carry out a number of duties. It is only proper that where it is alleged that the public officer abused his duty, the precise duty which was abused should be included in the charge… There can be no criminal abuse in the air," the judge said.

The judge found that the trial magistrate Mujaya appeared intent on stampeding Kasukuwere into a trial, ignoring his right to challenge the charges.

"With due respect to the first respondent the ruling (rejecting Kasukuwere's exception to the charges) does not show that he applied his mind to the legal issues raised in the exception… The failure to do so was an irregularity and misdirection making the review of the proceedings a necessity," said Justice Chitapi.

"… the particulars omitted from the charge and further requested for and denied would be reasonably required to inform the accused of the nature of the charge, but also because a refusal and denial of the same would violate fair trial standards."

The judge said a criminal trial was not to be treated as a "game of hide and seek but a pursuit of justice."

In his appeal filed by his lawyer Advocate Thembinkosi Magwaliba, Kasukuwere said Mujaya's ruling was "outrageous in its defiance of logic that no reasonable magistrate applying his mind to the exception would have arrived at such a decision."

Justice Chitapi said Mujaya had made comments that could be interpreted as taking the position that the filing of the exception by Kasukuwere was "an unwelcome intervention as he was on intent on the trial commencing."

When Mujaya urged Kasukuwere and his lawyers to "run with the courts and not walk when the court was running," Justice Chitapi said the magistrate was being "excitable", a point conceded by his lawyer Sharon Fero.

The magistrate had further made comments, when rejecting Kasukuwere's exception, to the effect that the prosecution had witnesses whose evidence was relevant, "yet no evidence had been placed before him by any witness."

"The impartiality of the judicial officer is a constitutional issue and it forms one of the cornerstones of the justice delivery system… It is important that in the exercise of the judicial function, the judicial officer must remain guarded and refrain from inter alia passing comments and remarks which may be construed as a compromise to the judicial officer's impartiality," the judge said.

A warrant of arrest was issued for Kasukuwere after he stopped attending court in May, resulting in the loss of a US$200,000 holiday home in the eastern highlands that he had pledged as surety for his bail. Justice Chitapi, with the agreement of the lawyers, did not address the issue which is currently the subject of an appeal by Kasukuwere at the High Court.

- ZimLive

Tags: Kasukuwere, Free, Court,

You May Like These Videos


There are no comments.

Latest stories

Zambia to double electricity prices

by Reuters | 17 September 2019 | 175 Views

Arsenal fumbles a 2-point lead to a draw against Watford

by Staff Writer | 17 September 2019 | 89 Views

507 Nigerians leave South Africa

by Mandla Ndlovu | 17 September 2019 | 121 Views

Teacher takes home $24 after maintenance deductions

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 186 Views

'Dr Magombeyi's 'abduction' the work of a third force'

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 167 Views

Bosso settle for British coach

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 167 Views

Arrested 'Zimbabwean' millionaire swaps jail for a swanky Maserati in SA

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 120 Views

Mnangagwa's govt shoots itself in the foot

by Editorial - Daily News | 17 September 2019 | 184 Views

Mukanya doesn't want to be buried at Heroes Acre

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 181 Views

Gold deliveries to recover: Mangudya

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 164 Views

Mnangagwa in surprise Chamisa cheer

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 190 Views

Zanu-PF, MDC battle for Zaka East

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 153 Views

Tagwirei, Wadyajena square off in US$3,6m dispute

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 92 Views

Mohadi in South Sudan state visit

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 147 Views

'Treasury instructed us to pay US$660m to Sakunda'

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 166 Views

Mnangagwa in tight spot over kidnappings

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 194 Views

Lukewarm reception for Mugabe's body

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 153 Views

ZANU PF scores own goal

by ZHRO Team | 17 September 2019 | 234 Views

Doctors paralyse Zimbabwe hospitals

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 194 Views

'Teachers' unions pursuing political agenda'

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 150 Views

Tendai Biti led team queries 'rogue' RBZ payments

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 174 Views

Police shoot car's wheels to stop smuggler

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 152 Views

Gweru sued over shoot-to-kill policy on stray dogs

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 133 Views

Suicide cases rise

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 123 Views

Witchcraft accusations land woman in court

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 145 Views

Fresh calls for price controls

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 144 Views

Abductions choreographed ahead of Mnangagwa's UNGA meeting

by Staff reporter | 17 September 2019 | 137 Views

Jonathan Moyo reveals Zimbabwe's abduction team

by Mandla Ndlovu | 17 September 2019 | 208 Views

Govt pisses on the graves over Mugabe

by Zororo Shumba | 17 September 2019 | 185 Views

Kings and Mambos must be careful

by Presia Ngulube | 17 September 2019 | 146 Views

Competition and Tariff Commission under fire

by Nicholas Ncube | 17 September 2019 | 142 Views

Mnangagwa panics over Paul Siwela TV interview

by Israel Dube | 17 September 2019 | 265 Views

Harare house burns with US$200 000 inside

by Mandla Ndlovu | 17 September 2019 | 216 Views

Sibusiso Moyo's statement on the abduction of Dr Peter Magombeyi

by Mandla Ndlovu | 17 September 2019 | 248 Views

BREAKING: ZBC CEO granted bail

by Mandla Ndlovu | 17 September 2019 | 176 Views

Zimbabwe Communist Party speaks on abducted doctor

by ZCP | 17 September 2019 | 220 Views