High Court dismisses OK challenge

High Court dismisses OK challenge
Published: 19 February 2018 (910 Views)
THE High Court has dismissed an application by OK Zimbabwe Limited challenging the pending disconnection of power at its shop in Gwanda over a $72 000 electricity bill.

The ruling by Bulawayo High Court judge Justice Maxwell Takuva follows an urgent chamber application by OK Zimbabwe Ltd citing the Zimbabwe Electricity Transmission and Distribution Company (ZETDC) as the respondent.

OK Zimbabwe Ltd sought an order directing ZETDC to stop disconnecting electricity to its premises at Gwanda NSSA Shopping Complex. The giant retailer also wanted the power utility interdicted from interfering with its possession of the premises or terminating electricity supply.

Justice Takuva said OK Zimbabwe's application lacks merit.

"The balance of convenience does not favour that the applicant continues to enjoy power that it has not paid for. To order otherwise would be against public policy, and in my view the applicant's contention that respondent, by threatening to disconnect supply, is resorting to unlawful self-help has no merit," ruled the judge.

Justice Takuva said ZETDC is authorised in terms of section 4(1) (a) of Statutory Instrument 155/88 to disconnect electricity to defaulting consumers. He said the applicant's right arises out of a contract with respondent and has nothing to do with the Bill of Rights in the Constitution.

"Equally unmerited is applicant's reliance on section 71 of the Constitution that deals with property rights. The fallacy of this argument is laid bare when one considers the fact that electricity belongs to the respondent. The applicant enjoys it as it comes, it is not applicant's property," said Justice Takuva.

"The applicant does not have a right to continue to enjoy power that it is not paying for. Accordingly, the application be and hereby dismissed with costs," said Justice Takuva.

OK Zimbabwe, through its lawyers, Joel Pincus, Konson and Wolhuter, argued that the $72 319,16 electricity bill was not authentic and lacked proof of legality.

"The respondent is taking the law into its own hands by threatening to disconnect electricity without a court order. The restated amount is in dispute, the respondent should first obtain a court order," said the OK Zimbabwe lawyers.

OK Zimbabwe argued that the disconnection of power is a violation of its fundamental rights enshrined in section 77 of the Constitution. ZEDTC through lawyers R Ndlovu and Company said it did not resort to self-help or take the law into its own hands but simply used its rights provided in the law.

"The applicant has not paid its bill. The respondent has an obligation to supply power to applicant as long as that electricity is paid for."

- zimpapers

Tags: OK, Court, Challenge,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

PHOTOS: Mphoko reveals Choppies 'V11s'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 46 Views

Joy for Shonas stranded in Kenya

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 181 Views

Madhuku blasts Matemadanda

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 80 Views

18+ useful_tips on how to get accepted to college

by Agencies | 10 December 2018 | 50 Views

'Luxury-gate exposes Mnangagwa's government'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 70 Views

PHOTOS: ZANU PF pre-conference venue

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 132 Views

Mnangagwa speaks on Motlanthe commission report

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 179 Views

Climate change to affect insurance business - Maguwu

by Staff Reporter | 10 December 2018 | 101 Views

WATCH: Mnangagwa pays US$40 at church

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 159 Views

Marange villagers seek to protect diamonds

by Staff Reporter | 10 December 2018 | 118 Views

ED's taken the politics out the economics, and given us all a brighter future

by Charles (student) | 10 December 2018 | 120 Views

Forex dealers resurface

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 136 Views

Jonathan Moyo tears into Murwira

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 120 Views

Austerity must start with Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 116 Views

Linda Masarira defends Chinotimba

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 126 Views

Bond notes have brought misery and suffering

by Munya Shumba | 10 December 2018 | 108 Views

Mandiwanzira trial postponed to December 18

by ZimLive | 10 December 2018 | 117 Views

PHOTOS: InterAfrica bus involved in accident

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 169 Views

Rural teachers march to Harare in pay protest

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 129 Views

Striking doctors accuse government of 'media propaganda'

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 114 Views

Mnangagwa snubbed burial of national hero Professor Makhurane

by ZimLive | 10 December 2018 | 417 Views

BREAKING: Former Minister Undenge acquitted

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 141 Views

WATCH: Mliswa clash with ZANU PF chief whip

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 134 Views

Tensions escalate in Zanu PF

by Staf reporter | 10 December 2018 | 147 Views

A paradox within the MDC

by Brightface Mutema | 10 December 2018 | 132 Views

Legal aid for unpaid workers expanded

by ZimJustice | 10 December 2018 | 118 Views

Mphoko to lose all Choppies shares

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 111 Views

Tendai Biti back in court

by Mandla Ndlovu | 10 December 2018 | 115 Views

The ED administration has made significant strides

by Nobleman Runyanga | 10 December 2018 | 125 Views

National Geographic Traveller lists Zimbabwe in Top 10 'must-see' destinations

by African News Agency | 10 December 2018 | 115 Views

Ziyambi chides 'childish' MDC MPs

by newzimbabwe | 10 December 2018 | 123 Views

Choppies exposes how they bribed Mphoko

by newzimbabwe | 10 December 2018 | 187 Views

USA's latest demands on Zimbabwe a red herring

by Mapozho Saruchera | 10 December 2018 | 147 Views

Motlanthe offers to mediate Mnangagwa-Chamisa talks

by newzimbabwe | 10 December 2018 | 246 Views

Angry motorists shut down fuel service station

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 205 Views

Italian clubs track Nakamba

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 160 Views

MDC - Zanu-PF talks would cost Mnangagwa the economy

by Staff reporter | 10 December 2018 | 167 Views