High Court dismisses OK challenge

High Court dismisses OK challenge
Published: 19 February 2018 (992 Views)
THE High Court has dismissed an application by OK Zimbabwe Limited challenging the pending disconnection of power at its shop in Gwanda over a $72 000 electricity bill.

The ruling by Bulawayo High Court judge Justice Maxwell Takuva follows an urgent chamber application by OK Zimbabwe Ltd citing the Zimbabwe Electricity Transmission and Distribution Company (ZETDC) as the respondent.

OK Zimbabwe Ltd sought an order directing ZETDC to stop disconnecting electricity to its premises at Gwanda NSSA Shopping Complex. The giant retailer also wanted the power utility interdicted from interfering with its possession of the premises or terminating electricity supply.

Justice Takuva said OK Zimbabwe's application lacks merit.

"The balance of convenience does not favour that the applicant continues to enjoy power that it has not paid for. To order otherwise would be against public policy, and in my view the applicant's contention that respondent, by threatening to disconnect supply, is resorting to unlawful self-help has no merit," ruled the judge.

Justice Takuva said ZETDC is authorised in terms of section 4(1) (a) of Statutory Instrument 155/88 to disconnect electricity to defaulting consumers. He said the applicant's right arises out of a contract with respondent and has nothing to do with the Bill of Rights in the Constitution.

"Equally unmerited is applicant's reliance on section 71 of the Constitution that deals with property rights. The fallacy of this argument is laid bare when one considers the fact that electricity belongs to the respondent. The applicant enjoys it as it comes, it is not applicant's property," said Justice Takuva.

"The applicant does not have a right to continue to enjoy power that it is not paying for. Accordingly, the application be and hereby dismissed with costs," said Justice Takuva.

OK Zimbabwe, through its lawyers, Joel Pincus, Konson and Wolhuter, argued that the $72 319,16 electricity bill was not authentic and lacked proof of legality.

"The respondent is taking the law into its own hands by threatening to disconnect electricity without a court order. The restated amount is in dispute, the respondent should first obtain a court order," said the OK Zimbabwe lawyers.

OK Zimbabwe argued that the disconnection of power is a violation of its fundamental rights enshrined in section 77 of the Constitution. ZEDTC through lawyers R Ndlovu and Company said it did not resort to self-help or take the law into its own hands but simply used its rights provided in the law.

"The applicant has not paid its bill. The respondent has an obligation to supply power to applicant as long as that electricity is paid for."

- zimpapers

Tags: OK, Court, Challenge,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Chivayo to start work on Gwanda solar project

by ZimLive | 23 March 2019 | 86 Views

Zimra official mauled by dogs at Chinese factory

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 75 Views

39 school kids feared dead

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 94 Views

BCC insists on forex for stands

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 61 Views

ED is not the only Mnangagwa: Jonasi

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 97 Views

Supa Mandiwanzira's passport return bid deferred

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 53 Views

Ivy Kombo back in Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 58 Views

Even politicians will not divide us

by Editorial - Daily News | 23 March 2019 | 53 Views

Mnangagwa moves to checkmate his rivals

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 54 Views

Musona fit for crucial AFCON encounter

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 31 Views

NetOne moves in to restore communications services

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 52 Views

Mnangagwa returns from Angola

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 57 Views

Mwonzora checkmates Chamisa

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 62 Views

When seers failed to see the Ides of March

by Bishop Lazi | 23 March 2019 | 67 Views

Zimbabwe's first black woman to get driver’s licence

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 55 Views

Zimbabwe begins regional power exports

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 52 Views

Cop steals car at police station

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 53 Views

Government starts fuel bonuses

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 42 Views

Zimbabwe marriage age of consent raised

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 35 Views

Mnangagwa is a listening President: Jenni Williams

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 28 Views

Cattle rustlers wreak havoc in Mat South

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 25 Views

Zesa to hike electricity tariffs in line with interbank rates

by newzimbabwe | 23 March 2019 | 150 Views

2 failed marriages, a broken past define Mukanya

by STaff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 208 Views

Spanking ban: Where to now?

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 122 Views

Search on for missing persons

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 154 Views

Beira-Harare fuel pipeline to reopen next month

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 119 Views

Hwende application dismissed

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 90 Views

Beitbridge modernisation to boost town's economy

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 108 Views

Govt dismisses cyclone rip-off

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 106 Views

Zanu-PF members urged to show loyalty to party

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 97 Views

Natpharm to fast-track drugs procurement

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 43 Views

Ex-Delta manager acquitted

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 92 Views

Harare resident sues council over parcelling of stands in wetlands

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 111 Views

Darikwa persuading Bonne

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 142 Views

Manager moans over US$50K adultery damages

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 94 Views

Cyclone Idiai deaths shoot to 259 in Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 23 March 2019 | 109 Views