Meikles suffers court setback in bid to overturn $3,6 million judgment

Meikles suffers court setback in bid to overturn $3,6 million judgment
Published: 26 February 2019 (205 Views)
High Court judge Justice Nicholas Mathonsi has dismissed an application to rescind a judgment compelling Meikles to pay over $3,6 million owed to the Infrastructural Development Bank of Zimbabwe (IDBZ).

According to the court papers, in 2016 Meikles Limited consented to an order being made in IDBZ's favour for the payment of the debt, but later Meikles said it realised it had a defence to offer in the claim, hence it wanted a rescission of the same judgment.

The listed conglomerate argued that government, which is indebted to Meikles, should settle the company's debt to the IDBZ.

The government debt, which is in the region of $42 million, arose after it assumed all the debts of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ), including one owed to Meikles after the central bank raided individual and corporate foreign currency accounts to finance the numerous farmer-support schemes the bank embarked on during the tenure of former governor Gideon Gono.

But the court said IDBZ was a distinct separate personality from the government of Zimbabwe in that it had a total of ten shareholders, including foreign companies like the Finnish Fund for Industrial Co-operation, the German Investment and Development Company, the Netherlands Development Finance Company and the European Investment Bank.

In his judgment, Justice Mathonsi castigated the conglomerate for its application, saying its proposed defence of indemnity "appears to be a pie in the sky".

"Does the applicant have a leg to stand on regarding the indemnity argument as to motivate a rescission of the order? I think not," he said.

"In my view, this is a case in which the applicant (Meikles) ought to have known that there was absolutely no merit in the application, even before the making of it.

"It is such a frivolous and, indeed, vexatious application as to amount to an abuse of process. This is particularly so, regard being heard that after consenting to judgment, the applicant only waited until the day of execution to engage in this misadventure, thereby frustrating the pursuit of a legitimate claim while buying time. The fruit of such a misadventure is an award of costs on an adverse scale. In the result, the application is dismissed with costs on a legal practitioner and client scale."

"Therefore, by the time the applicant was issued in HC9880/15 and later consented to judgment, all the facts that it proposes to rely upon in its newly found defence already existed. They are facts which it reasonably was expected to be aware of, especially as the respondent is a statutory corporation. This is not a case in which I can exercise my discretion in favour of the applicant," Justice Mathonsi said before dismissing Meikles's matter.

- newsday

Tags: Meikles, Setback, Court,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Restrain your wife - Mnangagwa told

by Methusi Ncube | 16 July 2019 | 178 Views

Mnangagwa-Army fallout deepens

by Mandla Ndlovu | 16 July 2019 | 130 Views

Auxilia Mnangagwa: A highly trained CIO spy

by Mandla Ndlovu | 16 July 2019 | 132 Views

MDC apologises to Mthwakazi

by Mbonisi Gumbo | 16 July 2019 | 91 Views

Smelly Dube scoops top UK award

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 105 Views

Attack on Mugabe coup announcer exposes polarisation

by Editorial Comment | 16 July 2019 | 142 Views

Kombi operators raise fares

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 159 Views

'Devolution a disappointment'

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 84 Views

Mnangagwa fumes over ivory, rhino horns

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 112 Views

MDC blames intimidation for by-elections loss

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 72 Views

Chamisa changes tact

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 128 Views

Zimbabwe's telecoms firms in revenue decline

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 72 Views

Paynet readmits 3 banks as alternative is tested

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 122 Views

Gukurahundi 'architect' threatens

by STaff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 84 Views

Chamisa's MDC has no more political depth than a finger bowl

by Tichaona Zindoga | 16 July 2019 | 105 Views

Zanu-PF youths take clean-up to UK

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 89 Views

Prophet in court for poisoning father to inherit his Mazda 323

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 77 Views

Chmaisa mustn't underestimate the electorate

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 86 Views

Mnangagwa hands over medical equipment

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 69 Views

Guard shoots self 3 times in suicide

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 91 Views

'Convicted thief' Kambarami fights for position at High Court

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 80 Views

Econet reviews data tariffs

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 83 Views

Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) engages political parties

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 76 Views

NUST hosts summit on fake news

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 46 Views

Suspected armed robbers, gold dealers in court

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 57 Views

Zvinavashe estate in shambles

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 60 Views

SB Moyo flies out to Lusaka on Friday

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 64 Views

Kambarami: A pig in royal robes still finds amusement in mud

by Ndabazabantu Sondokhulu | 16 July 2019 | 79 Views

Mnangagwa wants Mthuli Ncube to loosen his purse

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 66 Views

Mnangagwa's govt snubs civil servants again

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 64 Views

Chamisa worried about Chiwenga

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 99 Views

'Kill Mnangagwa and spare me, I've kids,' says his wife

by ZimLive | 16 July 2019 | 70 Views

Peter Moyo vs. Old Mutual: 7 key factors as they head to court

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 53 Views

Mnangagwa wife being watched by military

by newzimbabwe | 16 July 2019 | 72 Views

12 Cyprus scholarships for Zimbabwe students

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 46 Views

Zimbabwe scraps 15% tax on raw platinum exports

by Staff reporter | 16 July 2019 | 33 Views