President Mnangagwa flies into Chiwenga storm

President Mnangagwa flies into Chiwenga storm
Published: 31 December 2017 (1993 Views)
President Emmerson Mnangagwa's decision to assign his deputy Constanino Chiwenga the Defence portfolio has been described as a violation of the Constitution, which prohibits a vice-president from holding any other public office, The Standard reported.

Mnangagwa last week appointed Chiwenga, the former Zimbabwe Defence Forces commander and Kembo Mohadi as the new vice presidents.

He went on to assign Chiwenga the Defence and War Veterans portfolio previously given to Mohadi while the Zipra veteran was assigned the national healing and reconciliation department.

Former prime minister Morgan Tsvangirai's advisor Alex Magaisa said Mnangagwa had entangled himself in another potential legal mess after he was forced to change his initial Cabinet, which violated the Constitution.

"While he is entitled to assign the administration of a ministry to his vice-president, section 215 of the Constitution specifically compels him to ‘appoint a minister to be responsible for the defence forces,'" Magaisa wrote on his popular blog yesterday.

"The problem is that a vice-president cannot, at the same time, be appointed as a minister as that would violate section 103, which prohibits a vice-president from holding any other public office."

He said Section 215 of the Constitution was specific that the president "must appoint" a Defence minister. "It is not, therefore, enough for President Mnangagwa to assign Vice-President Chiwenga the role of administering the ministry of Defence because that does not constitute an appointment as required under section 215," Magaisa wrote.

"This means legally, there is currently no minister of Defence as required under section 215 of the Constitution, which is a constitutional violation.

"To cure this, the president must appoint a separate minister of Defence.

"Since section 225 makes the same requirement in respect of the intelligence services, the same minister would be responsible for Defence and security.

"He could, if he so wishes, assign Vice-President Chiwenga to supervise and oversee that ministry.

"If this is not corrected, civil society, the opposition or individuals can challenge the president and government through the courts in order to correct this legal misstep."

He added: "In this regard, it is important to understand that unlike other ministers, the position of minister of Defence is constitutionally defined and has a specific mandate."

Harare-based constitutional lawyer Chris Mhike said although section 99 of the Constitution permits the president to assign ministerial duties to his deputies, the Defence ministry was an exception.

He said Mnangagwa's decision to move the civil service to his office was also a violation of the Constitution.

"The consignment of the civil service to the Office of the President and Cabinet (OPC), and the assignment of ministry of Defence stewardship to VP Chiwenga are both highly controversial, and could reasonably be legally challenged," he said.

"Section 201 of the Constitution of Zimbabwe makes it peremptory for the president to appoint a minister who should be responsible for the civil service."

"Neither the president nor the OPC could be deemed to be "a minister."

He added: "Similarly, section 215 of the Constitution absolutely requires the president to appoint a minister, not a VP, to be responsible for the defence forces.

"There are many ministries, departments and portfolios that are not specifically mentioned in the Constitution, for example the national peace and reconciliation Portfolio, the ICTs and Cyber Security ministry or the Governmental Scholarships portfolio.

"The OPC and the VPs could be responsible for those without any dispute; but the civil service ministry and Defence ministry are certainly problematic as they are particularly mentioned in sections 201 and 215 of the Constitution.

"If the president, the OPC and the VPs cannot be ministers (as was suggested by the Constitutional Court in the 2015 NCA case), then the assignment of the duties and statutes under review could well be a violation of the Constitution."

However, constitutional law expert Lovemore Madhuku differed with the two lawyers, saying according to section 99 of the Constitution, it was lawful for Chiwenga to administer the Defence portfolio even if it was "politically unwise".

"The law says the vice-president can be assigned the administration of any ministry, department or an Act of Parliament," he said.

"So there is nothing unlawful with regards to that. But it is politically unwise."

But Madhuku agreed Mnangagwa had blundered by transferring the Civil Service Commission to his office.

"The law is very clear; the president must appoint a minister responsible for the civil service," he said.

"The word ‘must' is not optional, but instructive at law. So this transfer is illegal.

"It is a continuation of the illegalities we are seeing in this administration being perpetrated by so-called lawyers.

"At first they appoint nine non-constituency ministers, more than those stipulated by law. They had to reverse that after being exposed.

"Here again they have moved the civil service to the Office of the President and Cabinet when the law is clear that there must be a minister responsible for that.

"It shows that when it comes to constitutionalism, nothing has changed, in fact it is now worse."

Trade unionist Raymond Majongwe said the decision to remove the civil service from the Labour ministry was a violation of the International Labour Organisation convention on the harmonisation of labour laws for the both state and private sector workers.


- The Standard

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Mthwakazi parties seriously humiliated by MDC-T Bulawayo rally

by Nomazulu Thata | 18 April 2018 | 253 Views

Dembare fans boycotting?

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 111 Views

Armed robber up for murder

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 160 Views

Cheating Pastor in accident

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 263 Views

Zimbabwe marks independence from Mugabe

by AP | 18 April 2018 | 151 Views

PHOTO: Mnangagwa greets Chamisa

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 315 Views

Pizza Hut African Literacy Project Comes to Zimbabwe

by Agencies | 18 April 2018 | 79 Views

WATCH: Khupe takes a dig at Chamisa's bullet trains

by Staff Reporter | 18 April 2018 | 227 Views

'Zimbabwe not yet independent'

by Simbarashe Sithole | 18 April 2018 | 114 Views

Ian Smith's Legacy of Violence & Nelson Chamisa

by Mike, Bulawayo | 18 April 2018 | 137 Views

Nelson Chamisa: When 'gaffes' become serious

by Charles, student, Harare | 18 April 2018 | 167 Views

Zanu-PF youths scoff at Chamisa utterances

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 157 Views

LIVE: Zimbabwe independence celebrations

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 203 Views

Govt splashes out $66,000 to donate $3,000

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 137 Views

'Not yet Uhuru'

by Staff rpeorter | 18 April 2018 | 68 Views

Khupe opens new party offices

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 153 Views

Jostle for Jonathan Moyo's constituency

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 115 Views

War vets defend Jabulani Sibanda

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 131 Views

Plot to muzzle gukurahundi commission

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 88 Views

ZCTU calls for general strike

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 107 Views

WATCH: 'A World Cup without me wouldn't be a World Cup'

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 108 Views

Nurses defiant, laugh at Chiwenga

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 221 Views

MDC T students' council statement on independence day

by Fanuel Chinowaita | 18 April 2018 | 92 Views

An 'Independent' Zimbabwe is Possible says Jacob Ngarivhume

by Jacob Ngarivhume | 18 April 2018 | 72 Views

NPF independence message

by NPF | 18 April 2018 | 104 Views

MDC-T not opposed to the 'liberation project'

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 60 Views

WATCH: Khupe not worried by the supposed millions backing Chamisa

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 81 Views

Mugabes left official residences in 'terrible state'

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 105 Views

Khupe mobilising 4,000 delegates for congress

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 84 Views

Munyaradzi Gwisai savages Chamisa and his puppies

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 201 Views

Mukupe's behaviour stinks to high heaven

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 66 Views

Chamisa fears manifesto theft by Zanu-PF

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 62 Views

Chiwenga ex-wife falls on hard times

by Staff rpeorter | 18 April 2018 | 131 Views

Zimbabweans must surrender their fire arms

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 70 Views

'Zimbabwe has leadership crisis, not financial'

by Staff reporter | 18 April 2018 | 54 Views

Fengu praises Mnangagwa

by Stephen Jakes | 18 April 2018 | 65 Views

'Mthwakazi must shame MDC alliance,' says activist

by Stephen Jakes | 18 April 2018 | 63 Views